Pixar's UP

[Smartie]

Originally Posted by ..Rawr!..

I think that UP was pretty shit compared to the other Pixar films, Toy Story is got to be one of the best. CAN'T WAIT FOR TOY STORY 3!!! UP is so over-rated seriously... Whenever a Pixar film comes out, everyone says it is the best movie ever just because it is pixar but there are much better films than UP. Fantastic Mr Fox was actually amazing (It is genius!!) and so much like i thought the film should be.
I suppose UP is quite funny, the little fat kid, but really sad in places too... like when she died almost cried...

It made me laugh like fuck when the old men were fighting tho.. hahaha they got stiff!!
THEY GOT OWNED BY THEY'RE BACKS!!!

Contradictory comments much?

The point is that anyone with half a brain doesn't compare all Pixar like-for-like, because the stories are all different. If people are short-sighted enough to like Pixar films only because they're Pixar animations, then they must have a pretty limited ability to appreciate each narrative and piece in it's own right. That's like suggesting each Spielberg movie is comparable in their appeal, without considering the theme, content or context.

UP has much appeal I think, and has taken a more emotional diversion from the happy-happy kids world/action adeventure they so often are.